This is another one of the books that’s been on the TBR list for some time. While it’s not related to the overuse of social media, I thought it would be interesting to read about how social media is being used as “weapons”.
LikeWar argues that social media is being used by various groups to advance their cause – from Donald Trump’s campaign for the presidency to ISIS. Hence, the notion of a “war” taking place in cyberspace. Although the creators and first adopters of the internet saw it as a place where free speech would flourish and as a tool to take down authoritarian regimes, the book brings up several chilling examples of how this is view is flawed.
One of them is China, with its famous Great Firewall. The book describes the Chinese government as vigorously and successfully pursuing the goal of “control over not just computer networks and human bodies, but the minds of their citizens as well” through “the right balance of infrastructure control and enforcement”. The Chinese government not only suppresses certain terms, they also use commentators (the infamous 50 Cent army) to spread their version of the truth. And now, they’re also using paid social media ads – just look at how they tried to spread their version of events in Hong Kong on Twitter. While there are people trying to get around the censors using various words, it seems like China is largely successful in shaping the Chinese internet in the way it wants to be. A related op-ed points out that a combination of reliance on the same censored internet and a lack of critical thinking classes mean that even the Chinese who emigrate out of China tend not to broaden their thinking.
While China and other countries seeking to emulate it refine their techniques, turning the internet into several large fragments, those in countries with less control over the internet are not experiencing total freedom either. Social networks want to keep us hooked on their websites and to do that, they’ve created an echo-chamber. This has the result of amplifying extreme voices and reducing the amount of contrary opinions that we might otherwise hear.
LikeWar also looks at fake news or junk news as it was originally known. Apart from the unsurprising fact that people are more likely to share shocking and sensation content (which may or may not be factual), the book also takes a look at the people who create fake news, such as the Macedonians who accidentally stumbled across this money-making opportunity, something that I thought was interesting.
There’s also an interesting section on narrative. Stories that go viral tend to be simple, resonate with their target group, and contain something novel. If you can use these traits to control the narrative, you can “dictate to an audience who the heroes and villains are; what is right and what is wrong; what’s real and what’s not.” That is a lot and it made me realise that if a story makes you emotional, it’s a good idea to pause and try to figure out why it’s so – what is the value of me being emotional to the writer, what aims are there? I don’t think that every tear or rage-inducing story is necessary one meant to deceive me, but it’s always a good idea to be aware of when people want to manipulate you.
If you’ve been following and worrying about how social media has been increasingly used to further different narratives, I suspect that a lot of what you read in this book will be familiar to you. Still, having all the different threads – government censorship, fake news, the echo chamber, etc – in one book creates a big impact and makes you realise that the internet now is a far cry from the way it was meant to be. Sadly, short of intervention from other companies or governments, the only things we can do is to be more critical of the things we read and be on the alert for attempts to move us in one direction or the other.
This sounds like an interesting read–and very relevant to today. On a smaller scale, I sometimes will come across threads on Twitter in which someone says something, and others take offense and off it goes, spinning into something that isn’t recognizable. I sometimes find myself at the source wondering what I’m missing, if anything. And that’s just on the individual scale. I question just about everything I read posted on Facebook. It’s hard to know who and what source one can trust. My father-in-law is big about sharing things that aren’t true–and he believes them. Nothing will convince him otherwise (he’s a Trump supporter, as it is). I really do try to be discerning, but it can be hard to ferret out the truth sometimes.
Yes, there is so much noise and fake news that it’s hard to tell what’s real or fake. Take Hong Kong, for example, China is giving out so much propaganda that many of my family members are buying into the idea that the protesters are at fault
This sounds very interesting! In recent years I have become increasingly aware that when a “true story” (news / email forward / facebook post / whatever) neatly and “indisputably” confirms exactly what I believe, it needs to be examined with great care. Too often they overflow with half-truths, interpretive speculation presented as established fact, or outright fabrication.
This has been of special concern to me since becoming a pastor. As a Christian I firmly believe in the truth of the Bible, but I am frequently embarrassed by the gullibility and/or dishonesty of fellow Christians willing to wholeheartedly accept shoddy research or clear fabrications that “prove” some aspect of their faith. The whole point of faith is belief/trust without conclusive proof (Hebrews 11)…it’s not an unreasonable faith wholly lacking in evidence, but we look foolish and dishonest when we spread disinformation to make a point, and in the end “without faith it is impossible to please God.”
Your comment just reminded me of the story where people claimed to have found Goliath’s skeleton.
Unfortunately, Christians don’t seem to be above Whatsapp chain conversations. Perhaps the Church also needs to teach disciples how to discern if a news story is true or false as well
Yes, and the story of finding Egyptian chariots at the bottom of the Red Sea or NASA records somehow “proving” various instances where God made the sun stand still or move backwards…*sigh*
The (much older) story of archaeology confirming the existence of King Belshazzar in the teeth of historians’ unbelief is actually true and quite fascinating.
I’ve actually included teaching on being discerning with this kind of thing in sermons and Bible studies in the past… it was not well-received. Too many people would rather believe a fascinating lie that chimes with what they want to hear than be “wise as serpents and harmless as doves”…but that hasn’t stopped me from occasionally teaching about it anyway 🙂
It’s definitely a topic that needs to be taught. You’ve just given me the idea of proposing something like this to our youth group (: