I was under the impression that it’s been a long time since I read Rebecca, but turns out it was just four years! But because I watched the Alfred Hitchcock adaptation of the book and wanted to refresh my memory. Plus, I found a copy of Rebecca for 1 euro and it’s autumn so I was in the mood for this.
Since this is my third (or maybe even fourth) time reading this book, I’m not going to give an overview (tl;dr – the protagonist is jealous of her husband’s dead wife, the truth will leave you speechless) or try to review the book as a whole. Instead, I want to focus on how my opinions might have changed since the last time I read it.
I’ve got to say that this time, I can sympathise with the feelings of the protagonist a lot more. If I remember correctly, I’ve always felt she was a bit silly and naive and that led me to dismiss her feelings. But for some reason, the narrative voice this time was just so earnest and innocent that I really felt her jealousy. It’s irrational and she knows that, but at the same time, she can’t stop feeling the way she does.
On a related note, I have also realised how predatory this relationship is! Not only is Maxim de Winter almost twice as old as the protagonist, he basically only likes her because of how naive she is and that is why she suffers so much emotionally. This reread, I noticed some red flags at the start of the novel – like how he’s so dismissive of her and how patronising he is. Mild spoiler alert, but there comes a point later n the novel where Maxim basically says that “It’s gone forever, that funny, young, lost look that I loved.” The way I read it, Maxim’s “funny, young, lost look” was the protagonist feeling out of her depth at Manderly and suffering from a crippling sense of insecurity where she always lost to Rebecca. And at the moment she gains the knowledge to move past this, he says she lost what he loved. It feels like he liked having her ignorant and so dependent on him because it was the opposite of Rebecca and that is just so suspicious to me.
Finally, I’ve found two new side characters that I appreciate more now! One is Frank, who is more supportive than Maxim in practical and emotional terms and seems to be an overall dependable guy. The other is Beatrice, who is so straightforward and practical that I wish the protagonist confided in her. I like how Beatrice did her best to choose a thoughtful wedding present and present help the way she knew how, and it’s a pity that the protagonist didn’t manage to form a friendship with her.
Overall, I enjoyed this atmospheric and tragic novel. The writing is absolutely gorgeous without being purple prose and I really appreciate how I have new takeaways every time I read it.
P.s. This has nothing to do with the book BUT I brought this to read while on the way to meet a friend for a hike, so I snapped a picture of the book in the wilderness! But the hike at Mont Gros was really beautiful so I wanted to share some pictures with you too!
I totally agree with your comments about Maxim. That’s why I enjoyed this book so much—it’s unsettling. Likewise, I love the creepiness and ambiguous ending of My Cousin Rachel.
I can’t remember if I read My Cousin Rachel, but I watched the movie and I remember enjoying it (and now I feel like reading it haha).
I never saw the movie so I don’t know how they compare. It’s been ages since I read it so I may have to pull out my copy too!
I went to check my goodreads and turns out, I have read the book and enjoyed it!!
Beautiful pictures! The semiarid, Mediterranean look actually reminds me of my home state. But here, we are many miles from the sea.
I’ve only read Rebecca once so far. Then, recently I watched a movie adaptation. What really came out to me in the adaptation was the harshness of the class system in both the book and the movie. Because the protagonist is both educated and not upper class, there is no comfortable place for her. Her employer treats her like dirt, then despises her when she finds out Maxim wants to marry her, writing her off as a gold digger. You’d think that by marrying Maxim, she would move up in class status, but instead, the servants hate her because she is not to the manor born and she’s more trapped than ever.
I did think Maxim failed to take into account the stress that his new young wife would be under when he brought her back to Manderley. It’s as if he forgot that she had feelings and had a right to know the history. I didn’t pick up on a vibe that he wanted to keep her dependent, more just that he intentionally chose someone as different from Rebecca as possible. But now with this lens, I can see that he’s also patronizing. The way that he proposes, for example, is really inconsiderate and leaves her totally disoriented.
Good point about the class issues – I didn’t really think about that. She’s in that weird in between state, a bit like Jane Fairfax in Emma!
Maxim just assumed so many things, especially about her ability to adapt so quickly!!
Thank you for your thoughtful comment!
Wow what gorgeous views!!!
Totally worth bringing a book on the hike! (And as a hike, it wasn’t too bad as well)