EusReads

Book Review: The Nine Tailors by Dorothy L. Sayers

I heard great things about The Nine Tailors from The Golden Age of Murder so I had to borrow it. While I enjoyed the book, it felt very familiar, as though I had read it before. So I went to Goodreads and… I’ve read this seven years ago! This is shaping up to be the year of unintentional re-reads.

The Nine Tailors sees Lord Peter in the East Anglian countryside. What starts off as a mechanical fault soon turns into a nine-hour course of bell ringing (of course, Wimsey knows how to ring a Church bell). That’s all and good but some time after, Wimsey receives a letter from the Rector, notifying him of the discovery of an unknown corpse and asking for his help.

Unlike my first read, where I was more-or-less ambivalent/meh about the book, I had a lot more fun. Perhaps it’s because I’m already used to Wimsey’s character or perhaps it’s because I’ve already read about all the bells once but I wasn’t bored. While the mystery wasn’t as fast-paced as some modern mysteries are, the book provides some wonderful dialogue and characterisation and that’s what I really enjoyed.

I don’t know if it’s typical of the Sayers but this is the book where I realised how skilled she is with using speech to make her characters distinctive. There’s a lot of dialogue and many new characters, but it never felt heavy or had the “talking heads” problem for me. In fact, I enjoyed the dialogue because the digressions that each character took was what made them come to life. For example, the Rector is prone to digressions and can start rambling about his beloved Church and bells at the slightest prompting, while his wife’s replies show that she’s the one who lovingly keeps track of things like keys and the welfare of his visitors. I genuinely enjoyed reading their interactions and had a good sense of who they were as people.

The Nine Tailors goes beyond the mystery to bring to life a small village and its Church Bells. Perhaps the younger me couldn’t appreciate that, but present me very much enjoyed the story.

4 thoughts on “Book Review: The Nine Tailors by Dorothy L. Sayers

  1. Interesting. I like Lord Peter mysteries but have never encountered this one.

    Sayers does tend to get off on tangents. Usually I enjoy them, because I learn something. I love the one where Lord Peter goes undercover to work for an advertising agency and we get a hilarious glimpse of the agency’s office politics.

    Sometimes the tangents have an “I’m so much smarter than you” feel to them. In one book, many pages are devoted to Lord Peter and Harriet cracking a cipher code that I just couldn’t follow.

    But the church bells sound interesting.

    1. I’ve heard about the advertising one too! That’s on my list to read. To be honest, I still don’t understand bell ringing but everyone’s so enthusiastic about it that I don’t get any “I’m smarter than you” vibes from the book (even though they are smarter than me in this!)

  2. As a younger reader, I can one hundred percent say that I agree with this review. I had to read this book for my freshman summer book assignment and while I don’t think I appreciated it much now, I hope that in the future I can reread this book and truly appreciate all of the attention to detail and everything far beyond the mystery.

    1. I hope you’ll have the chance to return to this! I didn’t really like Sayer’s mysteries as much when I was younger either – it’s only been the past few years where I started to enjoy her.

What do you think?